Executive Summary
This PhD thesis evaluates the UK's Defence Industrial Strategy (DIS) from 1998-2023, focusing on its impact on aerospace procurement and the sustainability of the defense industrial base. It concludes that DIS has had minimal impact due to formulation shortcomings, misaligned funding, and cultural barriers, despite some positive shifts in DSIS 2021.
Why It Matters
This document provides a critical academic assessment of the UK's defense industrial strategy, highlighting systemic issues in procurement and industrial base sustainability that impact national security and deterrence.
Key Takeaways
- UK Defence Industrial Strategies (DIS) from 1998-2023 have largely failed to improve aerospace project performance or sustain the industrial base due to flawed formulation and implementation.
Source evidence · PDF page 3
In conclusion, the research identified shortcomings in the formulation of DIS in the treatment of sovereign capability and operational independence, future technology requirements and the optimisation of the routes to contract.
- Key barriers to DIS effectiveness include a lack of harmonization between strategic objectives and available funding, as well as organizational and cultural resistance within the MOD.
Source evidence · PDF page 3
It also assessed that significant barriers to implementation arose because DIS objectives were not harmonised with the funding available in the equipment plan, rendering the strategies implausible through a lack of equilibrium between ends, ways and means.
- The 2021 Defence and Security Industrial Strategy (DSIS 2021) marked a positive shift with a more nuanced approach to competitive tendering, increased precision on sovereign capability, and greater emphasis on technology modernization and industry partnerships.
Source evidence · PDF page 124
In summary, DSIS 2021 accompanied by the creation of detailed sub-sector strategies represented a radical departure from previous approaches and thus had a very positive impact.
Strategic Relevance
The thesis critically examines the UK's approach to defense industrial policy, revealing persistent challenges in procurement, financial management, and maintaining sovereign capabilities. These issues directly impact the UK's ability to equip its armed forces, sustain its defense industrial base, and project credible deterrence.